Constitutionalizing Gladue Rights: Critical Perspectives and Prospective Paths Forward

Authors

  • Hardie Rath-Wilson

Abstract

While remedial sentencing practices for Indigenous accused in Canada have often been described in rights-based terms, Canadian jurisprudence has been reluctant to characterize s. 718.2(e) of the Criminal Code as an actual “right.” At the same time, front-line judges who are witnesses to — and complicit in — the systemic overincarceration of Indigenous people have created something more out of Gladue than a Criminal Code sentencing guideline. Indeed, they have followed our apex Court’s direction that “application of the Gladue principles is required in every case involving an Aboriginal offender.” Following a few recent expansions of Gladue into yet more spheres of the administration of colonial justice, this paper investigates whether there is utility in reconceiving Gladue as a Charter right. While the substantive and theoretical criticisms of the legal policy mechanism of Gladue are valid, binding judicial and administrative decision-makers with a Charter responsibility to consider the particular circumstances of Indigenous realities when liberty interests of an accused are at stake can serve to strengthen the check on colonial maladministration of justice.

Downloads

Published

2022-01-13