Consilient evidence affirms expansive stabilizing ligaments in the tyrannosaurid foot
Keywords:Dinosauria, Tyrannosauridae, ligament, enthesis, histology, SEM
Tyrannosaurid dinosaurs were ecologically unique vertebrates as the sole clade of large terrestrial carnivores (adults >400 kg) in their continent-spanning habitats. Expanded ligaments between metatarsals, inferred by gross morphology of attachment correlates, have been hypothesized to have strengthened their specialized arctometatarsus. We tested the hypothesis of ligament presence with scanning electron microscopy and histological thin sections of putative attachment sites in a third metatarsal of the tyrannosaurid Gorgosaurus libratus, compared with a thin section from the unspecialized metatarsals of the early theropod Coelophysis bauri. In the Gorgosaurus metatarsal, Sharpey´s fibers and rough, pitted surface textures consistent with ligament coalescence occur at expansive distal regions and localized rugosities are ideally located for resisting torsional loading on the foot. Sparser Sharpey’s fibers occur at expected locations in other arctometatarsus-bearing coelurosaurs. In contrast, the Coelophysis metatarsal lacked Sharpey’s fibers or rugosity at the sectioned location, acting as a definitive negative control for identifying these features in tyrannosaurids. With soft-tissue correlates confirmed as ligament entheses, we conclude that tyrannosaurids possessed distinctive and specific ligament attachments to the third metatarsal lacking in other large carnivorous dinosaurs. Histological evidence for extensive distal intermetatarsal ligaments is consistent with greater inferred agility in derived tyrannosaurid dinosaurs than in earlier lineages of large theropods.
Apostolakos J., T.J. Durant. C.R. Dwyer, R.P. Russell, J.H. Weinreb, F. Alaee, K. Beitzel, M.B. McCarthy, M.P. Cote, and A.D. Mazzocca. 2014. The enthesis: a review of the tendon-to-bone insertion. Muscles Ligaments Tendons Journal 4:333−342.
Bates, K.T., and P.L. Falkingham. 2012. Estimating maximum bite force in Tyrannosaurus rex using multi-body dynamics. Biology Letters 8:660–664.
Bates K.T, and P.L. Falkingham. 2018. The importance of muscle architecture in biomechanical reconstructions of extinct animals: a case study using Tyrannosaurus rex. Journal of Anatomy 233:625–635.
Benjamin, M., T. Kumai, S. Milz, B.M. Boszczyk, A.A. Boscczyk, and J.R. Ralphs. 2002. The skeletal attachment of tendons – tendon ‘entheses’. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part A: Molecular & Integrative Physiology 133:931−945.
Biewener, A.A. 2005. Review: biomechanical consequences of scaling. Journal of Experimental Biology 208:1665−1676.
Bronzatti, M., R.B.J. Benson, S.W. Evers, M.D. Ezcurra, S.F. Cabreira, J. Choiniere, K.N. Dollman, A. Paulina-Carabajal, V.J. Badermacher, L. Roberto-da Silva, G. Sobral, M.R. Stocker, L.M. Witmer, M.C. Langer, and S.J. Nesbitt. 2021. Deep evolutionary diversification of semicircular canals in archosaurs. Current Biology 31:1−10.
Brown, C.M., A.P. Russell, and M.J. Ryan. 2009. Pattern and transition of surficial bone texture of the centrosaurine frill and their ontogenetic and taxonomic implications. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 29:132−141.
Brusatte, S.L., M.A Norell, T.D. Carr, G.M. Erickson, J.R. Hutchinson, A.M. Balanoff, G.S. Bever, J.N Choinere, P.J. Makovicky, and X. Xu. Tyrannosaur paleobiology: new research on ancient exemplar organisms. Science 329:1481−1485.
Bryant, H.N., and A.P. Russell. 1992. The role of phylogenetic analysis in the inference of unpreserved attributes of extinct taxa. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 337:405–418.
Carrano, M.T. 1998. What, if anything, is a cursor? Categories versus continua for determining locomotor habit in mammals and dinosaurs. Journal of Zoology, London 247:29−42.
Carrier, D.R., R.M. Walter, and D.V. Lee. 2001. Influence of rotational inertia on turning performance of theropod dinosaurs: clues from humans with increased rotational inertia. Journal of Experimental Biology 204:3917–3926.
Carter, D.R., and G.S. Beaupré. 2001. Skeletal tissue histomorphology and mechanics; pp. 31−52 in D.R. Carter and G.S. Beaupré (eds.), Skeletal Function and Form: Mechanobiology of Skeletal Development, Aging, and Regeneration. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
Colbert, E.H. 1989. The Triassic dinosaur Coelophysis. Museum of Northern Arizona Bulletin. 57:1–160.
Coombs, W.P. Jr. 1978. Theoretical aspects of cursorial adaptations in dinosaurs. The Quarterly Review of Biology 53:393−418.
Cost, I. N., K.M. Middleton, K.C. Sellers, M.S. Echols, L.M. Witmer, J.L. Davis, and C.M. Holliday. 2019. Palatal biomechanics and its significance for cranial kinesis in Tyrannosaurus rex. The Anatomical Record 303:999–1017.
Cox, P.G., and N. Jeffery. 2010. Semicircular canals and agility: the influence of size and shape measures. Journal of Anatomy 216:37−47.
Cullen, T.M., D.C. Evans, M.J. Ryan, P.J. Currie, and Y. Kobayashi. 2014. Osteohistological variation in growth marks and osteocyte lacunar density in a theropod dinosaur (Coelurosauria: Ornithomimidae). BMC Evolutionary Biology 14:231.
Dececchi, T.A., A.M. Mloszewska, T.R. Holtz, Jr., M.B. Habib, and H.C.E. Larsson. 2020. The fast and the frugal: Divergent locomotory strategies drive limb lengthening in theropod dinosaurs. PLoS ONE 15(5): e0223698. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. pone.0223698
Ely, E.R., C.S Avella, J.S. Price, R.K.W Smith, J.L.N Wood, and K.L.P Verheyen. 2009. Descriptive epidemiology of fracture, tendon and suspensory ligament injuries in National Hunt racehorses in training. Equine Veterinary Journal 41:372−378.
Erickson, G.M., P.J. Makovicky, P.J. Currie, M.A. Norell, S.A. Yerby, and C.A. Brochu. 2004. Gigantism and comparative life-history parameters of tyrannosaurid dinosaurs. Nature 430:772−778.
Erickson, G.M., S.D. Van Kirk, J. Su, M.E. Levenston., W.E. Caler, and D.R. Carter. 1996. Bite-force estimation for Tyrannosaurus rex from tooth-marked bones. Nature 382:706−708.
Erickson, G.M., K.C. Rogers, D.J. Varricchio, M.A. Norell, and X. Xu. 2007. Growth patterns in brooding dinosaurs reveals the timing of sexual maturity in non-avian dinosaurs and genesis of the avian condition. Biology Letters 3:558–561.
Ezcurra, M.D. 2017. A new early coelophysoid neotheropod from the Late Triassic of northwestern Argentina. Ameghiniana 54:506–538.
Farlow, J.O., and T.R. Holtz, Jr. 2002. The fossil record of predation in dinosaurs; pp. 251−266 in M. Kowalewski and P.H. Kelley (eds.), The Fossil Record of Predation (The Paleontological Society Papers, Volume 8. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
Funston, G., P. Currie, and M. Burns. 2016. New elmisaurine specimens from North America and their relationship to the Mongolian Elmisaurus rarus. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 61:159–173.
Gignac, P.M., and G.M. Erickson. 2017. The biomechanics behind extreme osteophagy in Tyrannosaurus rex. Scientific Reports 7:2012
Hadziselimovic, H., and L.J. Savkovic. 1964. Appearance of semicircular canals in birds in relation to mode of life. Acta Anatomica 57:306–315.
Henderson, D.M., and E. Snively. 2003. Tyrannosaurus en pointe: allometry minimized rotational inertia of large carnivorous dinosaurs. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Biology Letters 271:S57−S60.
Holtz, T.R., Jr. 2021. Theropod guild structure and the tyrannosaurid niche assimilation hypothesis: implications for predatory dinosaur macroecology and ontogeny in later Late Cretaceous Asiamerica. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 58:778−795.
Holtz, T.R., Jr. 2004. Taxonomic diversity, morphological disparity, and guild structure in theropod carnivore communities: implications for paleoecology and life history strategies in tyrant dinosaurs. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 24(Suppl. 3):72A.
Holtz, T.R., Jr. 2002. Theropod predation: evidence and ecomorphology; pp. 325−340 in P.H. Kelly, M. Koweleski and T.A. Hansen (eds.), Predator−Prey Interactions in the Fossil Record. Topics in Geobiology 17. Kluwer/Plenum, New York.
Holtz, T.R., Jr. 2001. Arctometatarsalia revisited: the problem of homoplasy in reconstructing theropod phylogeny; pp. 99−121 in J. Gauthier and L.F. Gall (eds.), New Perspectives on the Origin and Early Evolution of Birds: Proceedings of the International Symposium in Honor of John H. Ostrom. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT.
Holtz, T.R., Jr. 1995. The arctometatarsalian pes, an unusual structure of the metatarsus of Cretaceous Theropoda (Dinosauria: Saurischia). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 14:480−519.
Hone, D.W.E., K. Wang, C. Sullivan, X. Zhao, S. Chen, D. Li, S. Ji, Q. Ji, and X. Xu. 2011. A new, large tyrannosaurine theropod from the Upper Cretaceous of China. Cretaceous Research 32:495−503.
Hurum, J.H., and K. Sabath. 2003. Giant theropod dinosaurs from Asia and North America: skulls of Tarbosaurus bataar and Tyrannosaurus rex compared. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 48:161–190.
Hutchinson, J.R, K.T. Bates, J. Molnar, V. Allen, and P.J. Makovicky. 2011. A computational analysis of limb and body dimensions in Tyrannosaurus rex with implications for locomotion, ontogeny, and growth. PloS One 6(1):e26037.
Li, D., M.S. Norell, K.Q. Gao, N.D. Smith, and P.J. Makovicky. 2010. A longirostrine tyrannosauroid from the Early Cretaceous of China. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 277:183−190.
Money, K.E., J.P. Londolt, M.J. Correia, and J. Laufer. 1974. Anatomical and physiological investigations of the vestibular system of birds. Brain, Behavior, and Evolution 10:212–227.
More, H.L., J.R. Hutchinson, D.F. Collins, D.J. Weber, S.K.H. Aung, and J.M. Donelan. 2010. Scaling of sensorimotor control in terrestrial mammals. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 277:3563−3568.
Nesbitt, S.J., R.K. Denton, M.A. Loewen, S.L. Brusatte, N.D. Smith, A.H. Turner, J.I. Kirkland, A.T. McDonald, and D.G. Wolfe. 2019. A mid-Cretaceous tyrannosauroid and the origin of North American end-Cretaceous dinosaur assemblages. Nature Ecology and Evolution 3:892–899. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-019-0888-0
Paul, G.S. 2005. Body and tail posture in theropod dinosaurs; pp. 238−246 in K. Carpenter (ed.), The Carnivorous Dinosaurs. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, ID.
Petermann, H., and P.M. Sander. 2013. Histological evidence for muscle insertion in extant amniote femora: implications for muscle reconstruction in fossils. Journal of Anatomy 222:419−436.
Qin, Z.-C., Q. Zhao, and X. Xu. 2019. Metatarsal II osteohistology of Xixianykus zhangi (Theropoda: Alvarezsauria) and its implications for the development of the arctometatarsalian pes. Vertebrata PalAsiatica 57:205–213.
Rayfield, E.J. 2004. Cranial mechanics and feeding in Tyrannosaurus rex. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B 271:1451–1459.
Rinehart, L.F., S.G. Lucas, A.B. Heckert, J.A. Spielmann, and M.D. Celeskey. 2009. The paleobiology of Coelophysis bauri (Cope) from the Upper Triassic (Apachean) Whitaker quarry, New Mexico, with detailed analysis of a single quarry block. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 45:1–260.
Sampson, S.D., and L.M. Witmer 2007. Craniofacial anatomy of Majungasaurus crenatissimus (Theropoda: Abelisauridae) from the Late Cretaceous of Madagascar. Society of Vertebrate Paleontology Memoir 8, Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 27(Suppl. 2):32–102.
Sellés, A.G., B. Vila, S.L. Brusatte, P.J. Currie, and À. Galobart. 2021. A fast-growing basal troodontid (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the latest Cretaceous of Europe. Scientific Reports 11:4855.
Schroeder, K., S.K. Lyons, and F.A. Smith. 2021. The influence of juvenile dinosaurs on community structure and diversity. Science 371:941−944.
Sereno, P.C., L. Tan, S.L. Brusatte, H.J. Kriegstein, X. Zhao, and K. Cloward. 2009. Tyrannosaurid skeletal design first evolved at small body size. Science 326:418−422.
Shaw, H.M., and M. Benjamin. 2007. Structure-function relationships of entheses in relation to mechanical load and exercise. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports 17:303−315.
Shychoski, L. 2006. A geometric morphometric and finite element analysis investigating tyrannosauroid phylogeny and ontogeny emphasizing the biomechanical implications of scale. MSc thesis, University of Bristol. 125 pp.
Snively E., and A.P. Russell. 2007. Craniocervical feeding dynamics of Tyrannosaurus rex. Paleobiology 33:610–638.
Snively, E., and A.P. Russell. 2003. Kinematic model of tyrannosaurid (Dinosauria: Theropoda) arctometatarsus function. Journal of Morphology 255:215−227.
Snively, E., and A.P. Russell. 2002. The tyrannosaurid metatarsus: bone strain and inferred ligament function. Senckenbergiana Lethaea 82:35−42.
Snively, E., H. O’Brien, D.M. Henderson, H. Mallison, L.A. Surring, M.E. Burns, T.R. Holtz Jr, A.P. Russell, L.M. Witmer, P.J. Currie, S.A. Hartman, and J.R. Cotton. 2019. Lower rotational inertia and larger leg muscles indicate more rapid turns in tyrannosaurids than in other large theropods. PeerJ 7:e6432.
Snively, E., D.M. Henderson, and D.S. Phillips. 2006. Fused and vaulted nasals of tyrannosaurid dinosaurs: implications for cranial strength and feeding mechanics. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 51:435−454.
Snively, E, A.P. Russell, and G.L. Powell. 2004. Evolutionary morphology of the coelurosaurian arctometatarsus: descriptive, morphometric, and phylogenetic approaches. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 142:525−553.
Spoor, F., T. Garland Jr., G. Krovitz, T.M. Ryan, M.T. Silcox, and A. Walker. 2007. The primate semicircular canal system and locomotion. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104:10808−10812.
Stein, K., and M. Sander. 2009. Histological core drilling: a less destructive method for studying bone histology; pp 69−80 in M.A. Brown, J.F. Kane, and W.G. Parker (eds.), Methods in Fossil Preparation. Proceedings of the first annual fossil preparation and collections symposium. Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona.
Therrien, F., and D.M. Henderson. 2007. My theropod is bigger than yours… or not: estimating body size from skull length in theropods. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 27:108−115.
Tumarkin‐Deratzian, A.R. 2009. Evaluation of long bone surface textures as ontogenetic indicators in centrosaurine ceratopsids. The Anatomical Record: Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology 292:1485−1500
Tumarkin-Deratzian, A.R., D.R. Vann, and P. Dodson. 2007. Growth and textural ageing in long bones of the American alligator Alligator mississippiensis (Crocodylia: Alligatoridae). Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 150:1−39.
Tykoski, R.S. 2005. Anatomy, ontogeny, and phylogeny of coelophysoid theropods. PhD dissertation, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas, 553 pp.
Varricchio, D.J. 1993. Bone microstructure of the Upper Cretaceous theropod dinosaur Troodon formosus. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 13:99–104.
Watanabe, A., G.M. Erickson, and P.S. Druckenmiller. 2013. An ornithomimosaurian from the Upper Cretaceous Prince Creek Formation of Alaska. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 33:1169–1175.
White, M.A. 2009. The subarctometatarsus: intermediate metatarsus architecture demonstrating the evolution of the arctometatarsus and advanced agility in theropod dinosaurs. Alcheringa 33:1–21.
Wilson, M.C., and P.J. Currie. 1985. Stenonychosaurus inequalis (Saurischia: Theropoda) from the Judith River (Oldman) Formation of Alberta – new findings on metatarsal structure. Canadian Journal
of Earth Sciences 22:1813−1817.
Witmer, L.M. 1995. The extant phylogenetic bracket and the importance of reconstructing soft tissues in fossils; pp. 19−33 in J.J. Thomason (ed.), Functional Morphology in Vertebrate Paleontology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Witmer, L.M., and R.C. Ridgely. 2009. New insights into the brain, braincase, and ear region of tyrannosaurs (Dinosauria, Theropoda), with implications for sensory organization and behavior. The Anatomical Record: Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary 292:1266−1296.
Witmer, L.M., R.C. Ridgely, D.L. Dufeau, and M.C. Semones M.C. 2008. Using CT to peer into the past: 3D visualization of the brain and ear regions of birds, crocodiles, and nonavian dinosaurs; pp. 67−87 in E. Endo and R. Frey (eds.), Anatomical Imaging: Towards a New Morphology. Springer Science & Business Media, Berlin.
Yun, C. 2021. A juvenile metatarsal of cf. Daspletosaurus torosus: implications for ontogeny in tyrannosaurid theropods. Acta Paleontologica Romaniae 17:15−22.
Zanno, L., R.T. Tucker, A. Canoville, H.V. Avrahami, T.A. Gates, and P.J. Makovicky. 2019. Diminutive fleet-footed tyrannosauroid narrows the 70-million-year gap in the North American fossil record. Communications Biology 2:64. https://doi.org/10.1038/s42003-019-0308-7
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2022 Lara Surring, Michael Burns, Eric Snively, Daniel Barta, Thomas Holtz, Anthony Russell, Lawrence Witmer, Philip Currie
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Submission of an article to Vertebrate Anatomy Morphology Palaeontology will be taken to mean that the article is an original work and not previously published or under consideration for publication elsewhere.
If the article is accepted for publication, it will be published on-line under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC By 4.0) meaning:
Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
No additional restrictions — You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.