Problematic putative pachycephalosaurids: Synchrotron µCT imaging shines new light on the anatomy and taxonomic validity of Gravitholus albertae from the Belly River Group (Campanian) of Alberta, Canada
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18435/vamp29388Keywords:
Stegoceras, Hanssuesia, Ornithischia, Cretaceous, Taxonomy, Ontogeny, Allometry, Sexual DimorphismAbstract
The taxonomic validity of the holotype and sole specimen of the pachycephalosaurid Gravitholus albertae (TMP 1972.027.0001) from the Belly River Group (Alberta, Canada), remains unresolved forty years after its first description. The diagnosis for this species is tenuous at best and extensive cranial fusion has prevented a thorough description and taxonomic referral of TMP 1972.027.0001. We used synchrotron µCT imaging to identify fused sutures and segment the individual elements that comprise TMP 1972.027.0001. This allowed for a detailed description of the specimen in a more thorough comparative framework with other known pachycephalosaurid specimens. Using new observations of contacts between cranial elements, the morphological distinction of TMP 1972.027.0001 from other Belly River Group pachycephalosaurids was tested with bivariate and multivariate morphometric analyses. TMP 1972.027.0001 is morphologically consistent as an end-stage semaphorant of Stegoceras validum. Furthermore, we find no taxonomically significant morphometric distinctions between Gravitholus albertae, Hanssuesia sternbergi, and Stegoceras validum, and propose the former two are synonymous with the later. Large Stegoceras validum frontoparietals show statistically significant dimorphism in the thickness of the frontonasal boss, which is not apparent amongst juvenile and subadult specimens. Pathologies consistent with intraspecific combat (“headbutting”) appear restricted to frontoparietal domes with proportionally taller frontonasal bosses, and suggests that the two morphs represent sexual dimorphs, rather than separate species. Foraminacephale brevis and Stegoceras validum are the only named pachycephalosaurids recognised in the Dinosaur Park Formation. The stratigraphic and temporal range of Stegoceras validum is extended into the underlying Oldman Formation. Pachycephalosaurid diversity in the Campanian is reduced as a result of these revised taxonomic hypotheses. A revised phylogenetic character matrix, recognising taxonomic synonymies and ontogenetically dependent character states results in a largely unresolved Pachycephalosauria.
Downloads
References
Baird, D. 1979. The dome-headed dinosaur Tylosteus ornatus Leidy 1872 (Reptilia: Ornithischia: Pachycephalosauridae). Notulae Naturae 456:1–11.
Brown, B., E.M. Schlaikjer. 1943. A study of the troödont dinosaurs with the description of a new genus and four new species. Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 82:115–150.
Brown, C.M., D.C. Evans, N.E. Campione, L.J. O’Brien and D.A. Eberth. 2013. Evidence for taphonomic size bias in the Dinosaur Park Formation (Campanian, Alberta), a model Mesozoic terrestrial alluvial-paralic system. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 372:108-122.
Brown, C.M., D.C. Evans, M.J. Ryan and A.P. Russell. 2013. New data on the Diversity and Abundance of small-bodied ornithopods (Dinosauria, Ornithischia) from the Belly River Group (Campanian) of Alberta. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 33:495-520.
Chapman, R.E., P.M. Galton, J.J Sepkoski and W.P. Wall. 1981. A morphometric study of the cranium of the pachycephalosaurid dinosaur Stegoceras. Journal of Paleontology 55:608–618.
Dyer, A.D., A.R.H LeBlanc, M.R. Doschak and P.J. Currie. 2021. Taking a crack at the dome: histopathology of a pachycephalosaurid (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) frontoparietal dome. Biosis: Biological Systems 2:248–270.
Eberth, D.A. and A.P. Hamblin. 1993. Tectonic, stratigraphic, and sedimentologic significance of a regional discontinuity in the upper Judith River Group (Belly River wedge) of southern Alberta, Saskatchewan, and northern Montana. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 30:174–200.
Evans, D.C., C.M. Brown, H. You and N.E. Campione. 2021. Description and revised diagnosis of Asia’s first recorded pachycephalosaurid, Sinocephale bexelli gen. nov., from the Upper Cretaceous of Inner Mongolia, China. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 58:981–992.
Evans, D.C., S. Hayashi, K. Chiba, M. Watabe, M.J. Ryan, Y.-N Lee, P.J. Currie, K. Tsogtbaatar and R. Barsbold. 2018. Morphology and histology of new cranial specimens of Pachycephalosauridae (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Negmet Formation, Mongolia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 494:121–134.
Evans, D.C., R.K. Schott, D.W. Larson, C.M. Brown and M.J. Ryan. 2013. The oldest North American pachycephalosaurid and the hidden diversity of small-bodied ornithischian dinosaurs. Nature Communications 4:1–10.
Galton, P.M. 1971. A primitive dome-headed dinosaur (Ornithischia: Pachycephalosauridae) from the Lower Cretaceous of England and the function of the dome of pachycephalosaurids. Journal of Paleontology 45:40–47.
Galton, P.M. and H.-D. Sues. 1983. New data on pachycephalosaurid dinosaurs (Reptilia: Ornithischia) from North America. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 20:462–472.
Geist, V. 1966. The evolution of horn-like organs. Behaviour 27:175–214.
Giffin, E.B. 1989a. Pachycephalosaur paleoneurology (Archosauria: Ornithischia). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 9:67–77.
Giffin, E.B. 1989b. Notes on pachycephalosaurs (Ornithischia). Journal of Paleontology 63:525–529.
Giffin, E.B., D.L. Gabriel and R.E. Johnson. 1987. A new pachycephalosaurid skull (Ornithischia) from the Cretaceous Hell Creek Formation of Montana. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 7:398–407.
Gilmore, C.W. 1924. On Troodon validus: an orthopodous dinosaur from the Belly River Cretaceous of Alberta. University of Alberta Department of Geology Bulletin 1:1–43.
Goloboff, P.A. and S.A Catalano. 2016. TNT version 1.5, including a full implementation of phylogenetic morphometrics. Cladistics 32:221–238.
Goodwin, M.B. 1990. Morphometric landmarks of pachycephalosaurid cranial material from the Judith River Formation of northcentral Montana. Pp. 189–201 in: K. Carpenter and P.J. Currie (eds). Dinosaur Systematics: Approaches and Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Goodwin, M.B., E.A. Buchholtz and R.E. Johnson. 1998. Cranial anatomy and diagnosis of Stygimoloch spinifer (Ornithischia: Pachycephalosauria) with comments on cranial display structures in agonistic behavior. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 18:363–375.
Goodwin, M.B. and D.C. Evans. 2016. The early expression of squamosal horns and parietal ornamentation confirmed by new end-stage juvenile Pachycephalosaurus fossils from the Upper Cretaceous Hell Creek Formation, Montana. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 36:e21078343.
Goodwin, M.B. and J.R. Horner. 2004. Cranial histology of pachycephalosaurs (Ornithischia: Marginocephalia) reveals transitory structures inconsistent with head-butting behaviour. Paleobiology 30:253–267.
Hammer, Ø., D.A.T. Harper and P.D. Ryan. 2001. PAST: Paleontological statistics software package for education and data analysis. Palaeontologia Electronica 4:1–9.
Hawkins, J.A., C.E. Hughes and R.W. Scotland. 1997. Primary homology assessment, characters and character states. Cladistics 13:275–283.
Jasinski, S.E. and R.M. Sullivan. 2011. Re-evaluation of pachycephalosaurids from the Fruitland-Kirtland transition (Kirtlandian, Late Campanian), San Juan Basin, New Mexico, with a description of a new species of Stegoceras and a reassessment of Texacephale langstoni. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 53:202–215.
Jasinski, S.E. and R.M. Sullivan. 2016. The validity of the Late Cretaceous pachycephalosaurid Stegoceras novomexicanum (Dinosauria: Pachycephalosauridae). New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 74:107–115.
Kilmer, J.T., Rodríguez R.L. 2017. Ordinary least squares regression is indicated for studies of allometry. J Evol Biol. (1):4-12. doi: 10.1111/jeb.12986.
Lambe, L.M. 1902. New genera and species from the Belly River series (Mid-Cretaceous). Geological survey of Canada Contributions to Canadian Palaeontology 3:25–81.
Lehman, T.M. 2010. Pachycephalosauridae from the San Carlos and Aguja formations (upper Cretaceous) of West Texas, and observations of the frontoparietal dome. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 30:786–798.
Longrich, N.R., J. Sankey and D. Tanke. 2010. Texacephale langstoni, a new genus of pachycephalosaurid (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the upper Campanian Aguja Formation, southern Texas, USA. Cretaceous Research 31:274–284.
Mallon, J.C. 2017. Recognizing sexual dimorphism in the fossil record: lessons from nonavian dinosaurs. Paleobiology 43:495–507.
Maryańska, T. 1990. Pachycephalosauria. Pp. 564–577 in: D.B. Weishampel, P. Dodson and H. Osmólska (eds). The Dinosauria. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Maryańska, T., Chapman, R.E., Weishampel, D.B., 2004. Pachycephalosauria. Pp. 464–477 in: Weishampel, P. Dodson and H. Osmólska (eds). The Dinosauria, second edition. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Maryańska, T. and H. Osmólska. 1974. Pachycephalosauria, a new suborder of ornithischian dinosaurs. Palaeontologica Polonica 30:45–120.
Nirody, J.A. M.B. Goodwin, J.R. Horner, T.L. Huynh, M.W. Colbert, D.K. Smith and D.C. Evans. 2022. Quantifying vascularity in the frontoparietal dome of Stegoceras validum (Dinosauria: Pachycephalosauridae) from high resolution CT scans. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology e2036991.
Owen, R. 1842. Report of British fossil reptiles, Pt II. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 11:60–204.
O'Reilly, J.E., M.N. Puttick, D. Pisani and P.C. Donoghue. 2018. Probabilistic methods surpass parsimony when assessing clade support in phylogenetic analyses of discrete morphological data. Palaeontology 61:105–118.
Patterson, C. 1982. Morphological characters and homology. Pp 21–74 in: K.A. Joysey and A.E. Friday (eds). Problems of Phylogenetic Reconstruction, volume 21. London and New York: Academic Press.
Peterson, J.E., C. Dischler, N.R. Longrich. 2013. Distributions of cranial pathologies provide evidence for head-butting in dome-headed dinosaurs (Pachycephalosauridae). PLoS ONE 8: e68620.
Peterson, J.E. and C.P. Vittore. 2012. Cranial pathologies in a specimen of Pachycephalosaurus. PLoS ONE 7:e36227.
de Pinna, M.C. (1991). Concepts and tests of homology in the cladistic paradigm. Cladistics 7:367–394.
Powers, M.J., C. Sullivan and P.J. Currie. 2020. Re-examining ration based premaxillary and maxillary characters in Eudromaeosauria (Dinosauria: Theropoda): Divergent trends in snout morphology between Saian and North American taxa. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 547:109704.
Powers, M.J., M. Fabbri, M.R. Doschak, B.A.S. Bhullar, D.C. Evans, M.A. Norell and P.J. Currie. 2022. A new hypothesis of eudromaeosaurian evolution: CT scans assist in testing and constructing morphological characters. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 41:e2010087.
Ryan, M.J. and D.C. Evans. 2005. Ornithischian dinosaurs. Pp. 313–348 in: P.J. Currie and E. Koppelhus (eds). Dinosaur Provincial Park: A Spectacular Ancient Ecosystem Revealed. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Schott, R.K. and D.C. Evans. 2012. Squamosal ontogeny and variation in the pachycephalosaurian dinosaur Stegoceras validum Lambe, 1902, from the Dinosaur Park Formation, Alberta. Journal of Vertebrate Palaeontology 32:903–913.
Schott, R.K. and D.C. Evans. 2017. Cranial variation and systematics of Foraminacephale brevis gen. nov. and the diversity of pachycephalosaurid dinosaurs (Ornithischia: Cerapoda) in the Belly River Group of Alberta, Canada. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 179:865–906.
Schott, R.K., D.C. Evans, M.B. Goodwin, J.R. Horner, C.M. Brown and N.R. Longrich. 2011. Cranial ontogeny in Stegoceras validum (Dinosauria: Pachycephalosauria): A quantitative model of pachycephalosaur dome growth and variation. PLoS ONE 6:e21092.
Schott, R.K., D.C. Evans, T.E. Williamson, T.D. Carr and M.B. Goodwin. 2009. The anatomy and systematics of Colepiocephale lambei (Dinosauria: Pachycephalosauridae). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 29:771–786.
Seeley, H.G. 1887. On the classification of the fossil animals commonly named Dinosauria. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 43:165–171.
Simões, T.R., M.W. Caldwell, A. Palci and R.L. Nydam. 2017. Giant taxon‐character matrices: quality of character constructions remains critical regardless of size. Cladistics 33:198–219.
Smith, R.J. 2009. Use and misuse of the Reduced Major Axis for line-fitting. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 140:476–486.
Starck, J.M. and A. Chinsamy. 2002. Bone microstructure and developmental plasticity in bird and other dinosaurs. Journal of Morphology 254:232-246.
Sternberg, C.M. 1945. Pachycephalosauridae proposed for dome-headed dinosaurs, Stegoceras lambei n. sp., described. Journal of Paleontology 19:534–538.
Sues, H.-D. and P.M. Galton. 1987. Anatomy and classification of the North American Pachycephalosauria (Dinosauria: Ornithischia). Paleontographica Abteilung A 198:1–40.
Sullivan, R.M. 2000. Prenocephale edmontonensis (Brown and Schlaikjer) new comb. and P. brevis (Lambe) new comb. (Dinosauria: Ornithischia: Pachycephalosauria) from the upper Cretaceous of North America. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 17:117–190.
Sullivan, R.M. 2003. Revision of the dinosaur Stegoceras Lambe (Ornithischia, Pachycephalosauridae). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 23:181–207.
Sullivan, R.M. 2006. A taxonomic review of the Pachycephalosauridae (Dinosauria: Ornithischia). New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 35:347–365.
Wall, W.P. and P.M. Galton. 1979. Notes on pachycephalosaurid dinosaurs (Reptilia: Ornithischia) from North America, with comments on their status as ornithopods. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 16:1176–1186.
Watabe, M., K. Tsogtbaatar and R.M. Sullivan. 2011. A new pachycephalosaurid from the Baynshire Formation (Cenomanian-Late Santonian), Gobi Desert, Mongolia. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 53:489–497.
Wiens, J.J. 2003. Missing data, incomplete taxa, and phylogenetic accuracy. Systematic Biology 52:528–538.
Wiens, J.J. 2004. The role of morphological data in phylogeny reconstruction. Systematic Biology 53:653–661.
Wilkinson, M. 1995. A comparison of two methods of character construction. Cladistics 11:297–308.
Williamson, T.E. and S.L. Brusatte. 2016. Pachycephalosaurs (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Upper Cretaceous (upper Campanian) of New Mexico: A reassessment of Stegoceras novomexicanum. Cretaceous Research 62:29–43.
Williamson, T.E. and T.D. Carr. 2002. A new genus of derived pachycephalosaurian from western North America. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22:779–801.
Woodruff, D.C., M.B. Goodwin, T.R. Lyson and D.C. Evans. 2021. Ontogeny and variation of the pachycephalosaurine dinosaur Sphaerotholus buchholtzae, and its systematics within the genus. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 193:563–601.
Wright, A.P. and D.M. Hillis. 2014. Bayesian analysis using a simple likelihood model outperformed parsimony for estimation of phylogeny from discrete morphological data. PLoS ONE 9:e0109210.
Downloads
Additional Files
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Aaron D. Dyer, Mark J. Powers, Philip J. Currie
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Submission of an article to Vertebrate Anatomy Morphology Palaeontology will be taken to mean that the article is an original work and not previously published or under consideration for publication elsewhere.
If the article is accepted for publication, it will be published on-line under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC By 4.0) meaning:
Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
No additional restrictions — You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.
