Perceived and Actual Search Behaviors May Provide Markers for Healthcare Utilization and Severity of Illness


  • Lindsay Alcock Health Sciences Library Memorial University of Newfoundland



health librarianship, healthcare utilization, search behavior, health information


A Review of:
White, R. W., & Horvitz, E. (2014). From health search to healthcare: explorations of intention and utilization via query logs and user surveys. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 21(1), 49-55. Retrieved from http://dx.doi/org10.1136/amiajnl-2012-001473


Objective – To gain an understanding of the relationship between online health information searching behaviour and healthcare utilization.

Design – Survey and log data analysis.

Setting – A software development campus and health information websites with servers in the United States of America.

Subjects – Two separate subject groups were used for this study. For the search log analysis, participants were randomly selected English-speaking users of a Microsoft toolbar who had consented to provide their anonymous log data. 489 volunteers who indicated they could recall their last visit to a medical facility were invited to participate in the survey.

Methods – To determine search behaviour, four months of data from 2011 were collected and analyzed from search engine logs. A unique user identifier allowed for analysis of individual search behaviour across multiple sessions, which then provided the opportunity to identify search behaviour changes over time. Search queries were labelled and annotated as symptoms, serious illnesses, and benign explanation based on curated lists identified in a related study. Erroneous synonymous entries were removed to increase labelling precision (e.g., astrology-related terms were removed for “cancer”). The researchers specifically noted searches signifying health utilization intent (HUI). Initial queries indicating HUI for each user were identified to determine whether or not there were changes in search behaviour prior to and following searches indicating HUI.

Perceptions of motivators related to healthcare utilization (HU) were gathered through a validated, anonymous electronic survey. Through fifty open and closed questions, participants were asked how they search for medical information online, how they locate medical facilities and scheduled appointments, and how their search behaviour might differ before and after HU. Survey results were compared with search log data to identify and explain trends.

Main Results – From log data, search queries focusing on symptoms increased prior to the first indication of HUI and decreased afterwards. The authors suggest that this increase may reflect a “heightened state of concern or uncertainty” (p. 51). As well, searches on relatively benign symptoms were observed to spike dramatically three weeks after the first identified HUI search, reflecting what the authors suggest may be related to users having been reassured through a visit with a health professional. The increase in benign symptom searching is supported by survey data. The number of symptom-related searches is shown to correlate with the number of HUI searches using Pearson’s correlation coefficient (r=0.64, t(78)=14.43, p<0.001).

Nearly 40% of survey participants searched online for information about a medical facility prior to a visit, and facility visits normally occurred within one (78%) or two (94%) weeks of the HUI search. Those visiting a facility for the first time were more likely to search for information related to the facility prior to the visit than those who had visited the facility previously. Knowledge level was observed to contribute to the results as well in that searchers with self-reported low domain knowledge were not only more likely to search for a type of facility rather than a specific facility, but were also more likely to visit the facility sooner after an HUI search than those with high domain knowledge. Low-domain knowledge participants were also more likely to self-diagnose, more prone to alarmist behaviour related to symptom severity, and were more concerned with medical insurance.

Survey respondents indicated that the focus of their searches prior to HU was primarily on symptom checking and potential diagnosis. Following facility visits participants’ searches focused more on specific conditions or treatments. In addition, respondents noted that the frequency of their medical-related searching for serious conditions reduced after they had been to see their physician, indicating that the initial perceived severity of illness was potentially alarmist.

Conclusion – Search activity, both perceived and actual, may act as a marker to HUI and as an indication that HU has occurred as well as the severity of the HU outcome. Information gleaned from user logs could be used to adapt and model search engine output for users both before and after HU. Further analysis on potential search engine output and geolocation is suggested to determine the full application of such data analysis.


Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Lindsay Alcock, Health Sciences Library Memorial University of Newfoundland

Head, Public Services




How to Cite

Alcock, L. (2014). Perceived and Actual Search Behaviors May Provide Markers for Healthcare Utilization and Severity of Illness. Evidence Based Library and Information Practice, 9(4), 51–54.



Evidence Summaries