Local Users, Consortial Providers: Seeking Points of Dissatisfaction with a Collaborative Virtual Reference Service

  • Kathryn Barrett University of Toronto Scarborough Library, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
  • Sabina Pagotto Scholars Portal, Ontario Council of University Libraries, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Abstract

Abstract

Objective – Researchers at an academic library consortium examined whether the service model, staffing choices, and policies of its chat reference service were associated with user dissatisfaction, aiming to identify areas where the collaboration is successful and areas which could be improved.

Methods – The researchers examined transcripts, metadata, and survey results from 473 chat interactions originating from 13 universities between June and December 2016. Transcripts were coded for user, operator, and question type; mismatches between the chat operator and user’s institutions, and reveals of such a mismatch; how busy the shift was; proximity to the end of a shift or service closure; and reveals of such aspects of scheduling. Chi-square tests and a binary logistic regression were performed to compare variables to user dissatisfaction.

Results – There were no significant relationships between user dissatisfaction and user type, question type, institutional mismatch, busy shifts, chats initiated near the end of a shift or service closure time, or reveals about aspects of scheduling. However, revealing an institutional mismatch was correlated with user dissatisfaction. Operator type was also a significant variable; users expressed less dissatisfaction with graduate student staff hired by the consortium.

Conclusions – The study largely reaffirmed the consortium’s service model, staffing practices, and policies. Users are not dissatisfied with the service received from chat operators at partner institutions, or by service provided by non-librarians. Current policies for scheduling, handling shift changes, and service closure are appropriate, but best practices related to disclosing institutional mismatches may need to be changed. This exercise demonstrates that institutions can trust the consortium with their local users’ needs, and underscores the need for periodic service review.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Kathryn Barrett, University of Toronto Scarborough Library, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Social Sciences Liaison Librarian

Sabina Pagotto, Scholars Portal, Ontario Council of University Libraries, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Client Services and Assessment Librarian

Published
2019-12-12
How to Cite
Barrett, K., & Pagotto, S. (2019). Local Users, Consortial Providers: Seeking Points of Dissatisfaction with a Collaborative Virtual Reference Service. Evidence Based Library and Information Practice, 14(4), 2-20. https://doi.org/10.18438/eblip29624
Section
Research Articles